Please select your home edition

Recycling myth of the month: Plastic waste is not just a 'developing country problem'

by Emily Petsko 16 Feb 13:20 UTC
Trash is shown polluting a waterway near Las Vegas in the United States. Once plastic enters streams, rivers, and other waterways, it can easily end up in the ocean © Shutterstock / John Dvorak

When the subject of plastic pollution comes up in the United States, Europe, or other Western countries, many people's first instinct is to dodge responsibility and pass the blame onto other nations.

"The problem isn't us. We recycle and we keep our beaches clean," you might hear someone say. "They are the ones polluting rivers and oceans with plastic trash."

They, in these conversations, are typically China, India, and smaller developing countries in Asia.

In 2019, then-U.S. President Donald Trump echoed these sentiments when asked about the ubiquity of plastic waste. "Other countries are not taking care of their plastic use and they haven't for a long time," he said. "And the plastic that we're getting is floating across the ocean from other places, including China."

While China certainly contributes to plastic pollution, recent research shows that Western countries are just as culpable - and perhaps even more so, since much of that plastic is Western waste in the first place.

A study led by oceanographer Dr. Kara Lavender Law found that the U.S. generated the largest amount of plastic trash in the world, disposing of nearly 92.6 billion pounds of plastic in a single year. Using the most recent available data from 2016, researchers determined that the U.S. produces six to eight times more plastic waste per person than its counterparts in China and India, respectively.

Europe's role can't be ignored, either. Even though Europe has a significantly smaller population than India or China, the European Union generated more plastic waste than either of these Asian nations.

Instead of tackling their own mountains of plastic waste, Western countries have largely outsourced the problem to the Global South. For decades, wealthier countries shipped their unwanted plastic trash to countries like Vietnam and Malaysia, which did not have the infrastructure nor the resources to properly dispose of them.

Too often, these countries were set up to fail because the plastics they received were never recyclable to begin with. (And as other researchers have highlighted, plastic has an abysmal recycling rate, with only 9% of plastics ever getting reused a second time.) With no viable alternatives, many of these plastics were burned or landfilled. Others ended up in local waterways, many of which led to sea.

That's why, when we look at places where plastic pollution is most prevalent, we must question the true source of that waste. If you factor plastic exports, litter, and illegal dumping into the equation, the U.S. is the third largest contributor to coastal plastic pollution, according to the paper by Law and colleagues.

"For years, so much of the plastic we have put into the blue bin has been exported for recycling to countries that struggle to manage their own waste, let alone the vast amounts delivered from the United States," Law said in a statement last fall, when their paper was released. "And when you consider how much of our plastic waste isn't actually recyclable because it is low-value, contaminated, or difficult to process, it's not surprising that a lot of it ends up polluting the environment."

That is slowly starting to change. China stopped accepting most imported plastics in 2018, and at the beginning of 2021, the EU banned its countries from sending non-recyclable plastic abroad. While it is encouraging that countries are starting to take responsibility for their own plastic waste, it is important to remember that plastic is a global problem that requires global solutions.

Even if one country was doing most of the polluting, as former President Trump insinuated, it makes little difference once plastics enter marine environments. After all, the world's five oceans are really just one big, interconnected body of water. Trump was correct in suggesting that plastic can travel in the ocean. Researchers have found that plastic can be transported thousands of miles, pushed along a "global conveyor belt" of oceanic currents. However, he overestimated China's role. It is difficult to pinpoint the source of a particular patch of ocean plastic, but the data shows it certainly isn't all coming from China.

Practically nowhere on Earth has been untouched by plastics. This difficult-to-destruct material has been found at the furthest extremes of our planet, from the top of Mount Everest to the bottom of the world's deepest ocean trench. Tiny microplastics, invisible to the naked eye, are in the air we breathe. Plastic knows no bounds - and that includes national borders.

Rather than finger-pointing, we must acknowledge that plastic pollution, like it or not, is the shared responsibility of governments and corporations in developed and developing countries alike. Oceana's plastics campaign spans the globe, with teams working in eight countries, plus Europe, to reduce or eliminate single-use plastics that far outlive their usefulness. We have already won policy victories that achieve this goal in Belize, Peru, New York state, and numerous cities across the U.S.

The plastics industry may have created this crisis by churning out an endless stream of single-use plastics, all while perpetuating myths about our ability to recycle them and pitting countries against each other in the process. However, it is now up to each of us to hold the industry to account and prevent plastics from overtaking our shared, global ocean.

This article is the third installment in Oceana's Recycling Myth of the Month series, which highlights common misconceptions surrounding plastics and our ability to recycle or properly dispose of them. The first installment explained what those numbers on the bottom of plastic products mean, and the second explored whether plant-based bioplastics are actually better for the environment.

Related Articles

Tips to reduce your vacation carbon footprint
What would happen if something negatively impacted your favorite location? When you're deciding where to go on your vacation, chances are that you choose a destination partly due to the beautiful environment. Tourism is dependent on intact ecosystems. Posted on 16 Aug
Speeding vessels exposed, threatening right whales
Critically endangered North Atlantic right whales need your voice today A new Oceana report found that most vessels are exceeding speed limits in areas designated to protect critically endangered North Atlantic right whales along the U.S. Atlantic Coast. Posted on 24 Jul
Pass the shark fin sales elimination act
The demand for shark fins is one of the greatest threats facing shark populations The demand for shark fins is one of the greatest threats facing shark populations around the world. Every year, fins from as many as 73 million sharks end up in the global fin trade. Posted on 17 Jul
Protect coasts from dangerous drilling disasters
President Biden recently took important ocean saving action to halt all new oil and gas leasing This past Tuesday marked 11 years since the BP Deepwater Horizon disaster - the worst ever oil spill in the history of the United States. Posted on 24 Apr
North Atlantic right whales are in trouble
17 new North Atlantic right whale calves have been spotted, offering us some hope Recently, a critically endangered North Atlantic right whale calf was struck by a vessel off the coast of Florida and washed up dead. The calf had deep propeller cuts on its back and head, broken bones and a cracked skull. Posted on 17 Apr
Living a life of harmony at sea
Liz Clark is a passionate conservationist, sailor, surfer and author of Swell A Sailing Surfer's Voyage of Awakening, a memoir which details her time sailing in the open sea while developing a profound connection to the earth and committing to a life of sustainability. Posted on 16 Mar
Save North Atlantic right whales from extinction
Use your voice to help A 33-year-old male North Atlantic right whale was spotted about 10 miles offshore of the Georgia-Florida state line entangled in fishing rope. A rope wrapped around his tail attached to fishing gear appeared to trail behind him - like an anchor. Posted on 10 Feb
Build an eco-friendly snow globe
To mimic coral spawning with materials found at home Once a year, an underwater blizzard with billions of colorful flakes occurs in coral reef ecosystems. This natural phenomenon is called coral spawning. Posted on 16 Dec 2020
New Kids Environmental Lesson Plans activity
Growing the next generation of ocean stewards Kids Environmental Lesson Plans (KELP) are free, downloadable marine science activities that encourage curiosity in kids and help them explore their surroundings. Posted on 25 Aug 2018
A foray into "Slimology"
What's sticking to my hull? How exactly does biofouling happen? It all starts with a biofilm, a complex living microbial community embedded in a thin glue-like matrix. Posted on 23 Aug 2018
Upffront 2020 Foredeck Club SW FOOTERSelden 2020 - FOOTERSeaview Studio 2020 FOOTER