Please select your home edition
Edition
Stoneways Marine 2021 - LEADERBOARD

Measuring conservation in a way that counts

by Bob Pressey 30 Jul 2021 02:43 UTC
The future of nature conservation lies in identifying where science and policy can save the most ecosystems and species © Robert Streit

A new study raises questions on whether current conservation science and policy for protected areas could be saving more biodiversity—with political and economic expediency often having taken precedence in the past.

Lead author Professor Bob Pressey, from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies (Coral CoE) at James Cook University (JCU), said the term 'save' in conservation needs to be better defined.

"Across the world, protected areas are established where they least interfere with commercial activities, even though those activities can cause decline and extinction," Prof Pressey said.

"But 'saving' means intervening in a way that prevents the loss of ecosystems and species," he said.

"There lies the problem. Business as usual means expanding protected areas where they make little difference while threatened biodiversity continues to disappear."

Prof Pressey said measures other than saving are used to assess conservation progress, and these are often politically convenient: money invested, km2 protected areas established and the number of species contained in national parks. These measures can hide a lack of progress in real conservation.

"What do these measures actually tell us about saving?" he said. "Not much. Real progress in saving biodiversity is measured by how much loss we have avoided."

While political, institutional and communication barriers are difficult to overcome, conservation measures need to be redefined. As an example, the study suggests the Aichi global Target 11 to increase protected areas to 17% of land and 10% of oceans hampers conservation. The target has instead motivated a race to increase coverage in the most expedient ways, both politically and economically.

Prof Pressey said there is a real risk that post-2020 targets will do the same unless they focus on avoiding loss.

"The future of nature conservation lies in identifying where science and policy can make the most difference—and then measuring, year by year, the difference made," he said.

The study brought together a team of scientific and policy experts from across Australia, Austria, and the USA. Their results will contribute to ongoing global discussions about the post-2020 global biodiversity framework.

"Better science is needed to demonstrate that we can predict where, when, and how we can most effectively save biodiversity," Prof Pressey said.

"And global policy makers need to revise their expectations and targets to address conservation impact, or avoided loss."

He said saving biodiversity means developing global guidance for all jurisdictions to implement local interventions.

"With this, we can achieve smarter and more meaningful conservation targets that go beyond the extent of the area being protected."

Paper

Pressey R, Visconti P, McKinnon M, Gurney G, Barnes M, Glew L, Maron M. (2021). 'The mismeasure of conservation'. Trends in Ecology & Evolution. DOI: 10.1016/j.tree.2021.06.008

Related Articles

DNA reveals the past and future of coral reefs
New DNA techniques are being used to understand how coral reacted to the end of the last ice age New DNA techniques are being used to understand how coral reacted to the end of the last ice age in order to better predict how they will cope with current changes to the climate. Posted on 22 Oct 2022
The double burden of climate change
A new study on the effects of climate change in five tropical countries A new study on the effects of climate change in five tropical countries has found fisheries are in more trouble than agriculture, and poor people are in the most danger. Posted on 9 Jul 2022
Fade to grey
Fish communities become duller as coral reefs die James Cook University researchers have found brightly coloured fish are becoming increasingly rare as coral declines, with the phenomenon likely to get worse in the future. Posted on 26 Mar 2022
Concerns as development threatens reefs
A stark warning about the impacts of urban growth on the world's coral reefs A new study has delivered a stark warning about the impacts of urban growth on the world's coral reefs. Posted on 10 Mar 2022
New data shows coral everywhere face catastrophe
The refuges will provide almost no escape Alarming new research shows global warming of 1.5 degreesC relative to pre-industrial levels will be catastrophic for almost all coral reefs - including those once thought of as refuges. Posted on 4 Feb 2022
Coral identity crisis
A new way to distinguish and identify coral species Researchers have found a new way to distinguish and identify coral species—providing crucial information to help manage coral reefs in a warming world. Posted on 30 Nov 2021
Corals roll with the punches
Corals may be able to cope with climate change in the coming decades A new study suggests corals may be able to cope with climate change in the coming decades better than previously thought- but will still struggle with ever-faster rates of climate change. Posted on 8 Sep 2021
More 'fairness' needed in conservation
A new approach is needed if protected areas are to be effective New research shows what is often assumed to be 'fair' in conservation practice may not be considered so by the very people most affected by it—and a new approach is needed if protected areas are to be effective. Posted on 12 Jun 2021
Time running out to save coral reefs
A window of opportunity to save the world's coral reefs - but time is running out New research on the growth rates of coral reefs shows there is still a window of opportunity to save the world's coral reefs - but time is running out. Posted on 13 May 2021
Half a trillion corals
World-first coral count prompts rethink of extinction risks For the first time, scientists have assessed how many corals there are in the Pacific Ocean—and evaluated their risk of extinction. Posted on 3 Mar 2021
2024 fill-in (bottom)Hyde Sails 2022 One Design FOOTERHenri-Lloyd - For the Obsessed