Please select your home edition
Selden 2020 - LEADERBOARD

Don't believe everything you see on the screen

by Max Shaw 13 Apr 2019 17:46 UTC
Fulanga beach © Max Shaw

When you sail in places like the US/Canada; Australia/NZ, or Europe, you can get lulled into believing what is shown on your laptop, handheld GPS or chart plotter is accurate. Looking at a chart plotter that shows your slip in the marina is pretty impressive. Move beyond these areas and four issues are quickly revealed:

  1. Not everything shown on the chart is actually there: We regularly see Aids to Navigation that have long since drifted away.
  2. Not everything that is actually there is charted: Many of the vector charts of the Tuamotus are based on some sort of analysis of satellite imagery, but many of the coral heads are either not shown or shown as being at "safe" depths when they are not. In other areas, the passes are stick-like cartoons without enough data to use for navigation or to decide when it is safe to navigate the pass.
  3. Selective display of information in vector charts: Lots about this is written elsewhere and was a leading cause factor of the Team Vestas grounding on the last Volvo Ocean Race (report here). As you zoom in and out on vector charts, you can see atolls appear or disappear.
  4. Datum error: Most cruising grounds were surveyed well before GPS was available. Therefore, even though the geometry of the features can be accurate, the position of the objects may be incorrect. You can use radar to estimate the datum error, but you need to be aware that each surveyed area will have different datum error. If you want to read more on this, here is one starting point.
Let's have a look at an example:

1 Here is a 1:625,000 zoom showing the approach to Tahanea in the Tuomotus. Lots of sea room to the south east, it seems:

2 Until you zoom only one level in to 1:500,000 and the atoll of Motutunga appears:

3 Motutunga circled in red. This issue was one of the cause factors in the Vesta's crash:

4 The little grey box gives a hint that an atoll is hidden there:

5 Of course, once you get there, there may not be a lot of data. This is a close up of Tahanea in CMap:

6 The charts for the passes are actually pretty good at this atoll:

7 Navionics has more detail on this atoll than C-Map, but some of the bommies that are marked are not there and some of the spots shown with 16 feet of depth are actually much shallower. It is suspicious when every bommie is 16 feet deep on the chart:

8 Okay, we are not sailing over Isla Isabela in Mexico at 7.7 kts. The datum for most of the Pacific coast of Mexico is off by a fair margin. We used the Garmin handheld for our first two years of cruising before we treated ourselves to a little chart plotter:

Tools to Mitigate the Risk

The first and foremost way to mitigate these risks is the Mk1 Eyeball, and careful timing when navigating critical areas. We try to go through passes between 1000h and 1400h and ideally, with the sun behind us so we can see the reefs. During these times, someone is always on the bow watching (clipped on if the pass looks rough). This was our main strategy through French Polynesia, but last year in Fiji a cruising ground famous for its yacht-grabbing reefs we also started to use SAS Planet to download, store and analyze satellite imagery.

SAS Planet is certainly not the only tool out there. Many sailors have success with OpenCPN (which we also use) and GEKAP. We also OVITEL Maps on the iPad, as it allows us to have a picture in the cockpit, but it can be a bit finicky to use and the iPad is hard to read in sunlight (and too bright during night watches!).

How We Use SAS Planet

Step 1: Download data

Select the area you want to download. You can do this by scrolling over the area at the desired zoom levels as you would with Google Earth, or you can use the polygon function to select an area.

Once the polygon is selected, you can open the selection manager (the green "check mark") and pick what zoom levels and which map source you want to use. In Fiji we usually use Google, Bing and/or Nokia. Sometimes a big cumulus cloud is over the critical part of a pass or anchorage, so it is nice to have alternatives.

Once the data has downloaded, it is saved in the cache.

Step 2: Route Planning

The rest of the process is personal preference and based on your risk assessment. Generally I plan routes in Coastal Explorer on the laptop and then export the route as a KML file. Using SAS Planet, the file can then be imported from the "Placemark Manager" and you can see your route and any marks you imported overlaid on the chart data. You can then check the route, at a detailed level remembering it is vector data, to see if there are any hazards.

If there are hazards along the route that regular charts do not pick up, you can then amend the route either directly in Coastal Explorer or by reversing the export/import process from SAS Planet to Coastal Explorer. If particular hazards are noted, they can be marked on SAS Planet and exported to Coastal Explorer and your chart plotter. I do this especially if there are particular hazards in a pass. Also, for very tight anchorages, it is nice to pick an anchor spot ahead of time to ensure adequate swing room.

The island of Yadua in Fiji is a good example. Below, a route is drawn with Open CPN into the western anchorage. It looks good until you export it to SAS Planet and find that you would drive over a reef. In Google Earth you can see the entrance but not the southern anchorage. With Nokia it is clearer on this occasion.

1 The western approach drawn in Open CPN:

2 Oh, except when you export it to SAS Planet you see you would have driven over a reef:

3 By using Nokia instead of Google in this case, the southern part of the anchorage is visible as well:

The other side of Yadua provides another example. It is a beautiful anchorage, near to a friendly village and excellent spearfishing. The entrance and anchorage are a bit tight.

1 The entrance to the eastern anchorage in Coastal Explorer. Note that the two red Aids to Navigation shown on the chart are not actually there:

2 When you look at the SAS Planet data, you see two coral heads in the pass that are not marked on the chart:

3 In this screenshot, you can see two danger marks on the coral heads as well as a possible spot to anchor with sufficient swing room:

4 And then this can be imported back into Coastal Explorer and the chart-plotter:


  • No tool replaces the Mk1 Eyeball and commonsense.
  • Just because Google Earth shows there is open water, it does not mean it is without hazards. To save data, some areas are shown as open water where there are actually reefs.
  • This is certainly not the only way to do this there are lots of other tools.

This article has been provided by the courtesy of Bluewater Cruising Association.

Related Articles

Wildlife Encounters – Sea to Sky
You just never know what you are going to see You just never know what you are going to see. That is an oft-heard sentence aboard Hoku Pa'a, usually said with wonder and joy as we reflect on the latest interesting sight, courtesy of Mother Nature. Posted on 10 Dec 2023
Tips and Tricks
A few tricks that aren't generally covered by the excellent courses offered by BCA In my travels to Alaska, Mexico, and two return trips to Hawaii, I have learned a few tricks that aren't generally covered by the excellent courses offered by BCA. Posted on 6 Nov 2023
Topolabampo to Alamos
A great sail from the islands off Puerto Escondido, Baja, to Topolobampo, Mexico We had a great sail from the islands off Puerto Escondido, Baja, to Topolobampo, Mexico. This crossing was bittersweet as we bid goodbye to our dear friends Bruce and Gina on Dreamcatcher. Posted on 15 Aug 2023
Rookie mistakes - And the things we did right!
We departed BC last fall, headed for our first year of long-term cruising We departed BC last fall, headed for our first year of long-term cruising, foolishly believing that we had read enough, learned enough, knew enough to avoid the mistakes that many new cruisers make - we were so wrong!!! Posted on 13 Aug 2023
Vancouver Island Cruising Experience (VICE) 2023
There is no preparation for going offshore quite like being offshore There is no preparation for going offshore quite like being offshore. You can do this by joining VICE 2023 (Vancouver Island Cruising Experience). Posted on 8 Jun 2023
Docking Theory & Practice
Do you find some docking conditions challenging? Do you find some docking conditions challenging? Whether you are a single-handed sailor, an inexperienced crew or a confident helmsman, you will grow new skills and turn your boat handling and communication from stress to success. Posted on 31 Mar 2023
January: Reflections on a Pandemic Escape
The Sars-Covid pandemic had again eluded all the attempts to stop it altogether As the festive season proceeded through the last days of December and the hoary Old Man gave over his powers to the bright shiny Newborn of 2022, we on Traversay III shared the very same, strangely inexorable feelings of powerlessness. Posted on 11 Mar 2023
10 more things learned while sailing to Mexico
The learning never stops One of the great things about sailing is that the learning never stops. Even at home in familiar waters, we'd learn new things every year. Now that we're voyaging, the lessons are coming much faster. Posted on 14 Jan 2023
Our planetary system from a sailor's perspective
Event in Canada: Navagating with the stars This in-person presentation at the BCIT Planetarium is for everyone and anyone who has looked at stars and wondered how anyone could use their location to navigate with. Posted on 13 Jan 2023
Electrical Skills for Cruisers
Spend a day with electrical engineer, Bjarne Hansen Spend a day with electrical engineer, Bjarne Hansen, in an interactive session about all things boat electrical. Posted on 30 Dec 2022
Selden 2020 - FOOTERGJW Direct 2024 DinghyHenri-Lloyd - For the Obsessed