Please select your home edition
Pantaenius 2022 - SAIL & POWER 2 LEADERBOARD ROW

Fred Again III - Lost on Reef in the Caribbean

by Rob Murray, BCA 29 Apr 2019 15:32 UTC
Fred Again III - Lost on Reef in the Caribbean © Rob Murray / BCA

I wrote for Currents about Navionics and the sonarcharts feature they enabled a few years ago (see article on page 28). Here's an update from an incident in Roatan, Honduras in February 2019.

Essentially, Navionics collects data from users and adds it to existing charts with a proprietary algorithm to enable additional detail, or detail where there was none before, and calls this 'sonarcharts'. In the areas we have been cruising, we have seen a marked increase in chart details and soundings, much to our delight. Combined with the 'community layer' (where users add details like rocks, points of interest, way points, etc. for the use of others) and the 'active captain' layer (similar to the community layer), e-charts did improve markedly. We have used the feature extensively ourselves, and found it was usually very good. In our experience, there has been no failure.

However, it seems it doesn't always work as desired. Fred Again III, a C&C captained by Robert Nuttall, was using the sonar charts layer as their primary charting system on approach to Roatan, and found the data sorely lacking. Nuttall had sailed from Vancouver BC down the coast and through the Panama Canal and had come to rely almost exclusively on the Navionics with sonarcharts for plotting. He had found it 'spot on' in his voyages and it had never let him down before. He had no reason to doubt its accuracy here.

Approaching Roatan at 2200 hours (after dark), he planned to use the chart to enter the anchorage in Little French Cay. The sonarcharts showed an open approach with minimum depths of some 15'. The Navionics or government charts showed the reef as shallow (too shallow to pass over), but did not show the true extent of the reef. Using either set of charts, or paper charts, would have delivered the same result, as all showed deep water where he went aground on the reef.

It appears the algorithm used to add new soundings and integrate them with the existing soundings interpolated the depths inside and outside the anchorage, 'smoothing' them to create a false pass over the reef where none existed. It also displayed soundings that were obviously incorrect over the reef. How this was possible I do not know. Combined with the inaccurate charting of the reef on the underlying hydrographic survey, it created the conditions for a disaster.

Now clearly, there were additional precautions he could (and should) have taken. He was after all approaching an unknown harbour at night, one with coral reefs. Prudence dictated staying offshore, perhaps a mile or more, until dawn and using Mk.1 eyeballs as additional aids to navigation to pilot an entry. If he had access to and had used a program to capture and display Google Earth images (like OpenCPN with the GE2KAP add-on, SASPlanet, or Ovitalmap), he could have confirmed chart details were in error with another source (Google Earth images are very good at displaying reefs). A cruising guide could have described the entrance and hazards, perhaps better than the charts. Radar might have shown the reef, but he did not have radar, and it is not always great at showing reefs. But those ideas aside, he was severely let down by the charts, which all mis-charted the extent of the reef by some 600', and in the case of the 'sonarcharts', showed an entrance to the anchorage that simply did not exist.

The captain and crew of Fred Again III were rescued without injury, but the boat is a total loss, will have to be removed at the owners expense and has suffered looting.

As always, mariners are cautioned not to rely on any one source of information, and to use all means at their disposal to make safe passages and landfalls. Aboard Avant, we will continue to use Navionics with the sonar chart feature, but we will use other charts more diligently, and Google Earth images as well.

The CBC featured an article about Fred Again III. Nuttall has a go fund me campaign set up to help him get back on his feet. He also maintains a blog if you are curious to read more about his adventures.

This article has been provided by the courtesy of Bluewater Cruising Association.

Related Articles

Wildlife Encounters – Sea to Sky
You just never know what you are going to see You just never know what you are going to see. That is an oft-heard sentence aboard Hoku Pa'a, usually said with wonder and joy as we reflect on the latest interesting sight, courtesy of Mother Nature. Posted on 10 Dec 2023
Tips and Tricks
A few tricks that aren't generally covered by the excellent courses offered by BCA In my travels to Alaska, Mexico, and two return trips to Hawaii, I have learned a few tricks that aren't generally covered by the excellent courses offered by BCA. Posted on 6 Nov 2023
Topolabampo to Alamos
A great sail from the islands off Puerto Escondido, Baja, to Topolobampo, Mexico We had a great sail from the islands off Puerto Escondido, Baja, to Topolobampo, Mexico. This crossing was bittersweet as we bid goodbye to our dear friends Bruce and Gina on Dreamcatcher. Posted on 15 Aug 2023
Rookie mistakes - And the things we did right!
We departed BC last fall, headed for our first year of long-term cruising We departed BC last fall, headed for our first year of long-term cruising, foolishly believing that we had read enough, learned enough, knew enough to avoid the mistakes that many new cruisers make - we were so wrong!!! Posted on 13 Aug 2023
Vancouver Island Cruising Experience (VICE) 2023
There is no preparation for going offshore quite like being offshore There is no preparation for going offshore quite like being offshore. You can do this by joining VICE 2023 (Vancouver Island Cruising Experience). Posted on 8 Jun 2023
Docking Theory & Practice
Do you find some docking conditions challenging? Do you find some docking conditions challenging? Whether you are a single-handed sailor, an inexperienced crew or a confident helmsman, you will grow new skills and turn your boat handling and communication from stress to success. Posted on 31 Mar 2023
January: Reflections on a Pandemic Escape
The Sars-Covid pandemic had again eluded all the attempts to stop it altogether As the festive season proceeded through the last days of December and the hoary Old Man gave over his powers to the bright shiny Newborn of 2022, we on Traversay III shared the very same, strangely inexorable feelings of powerlessness. Posted on 11 Mar 2023
10 more things learned while sailing to Mexico
The learning never stops One of the great things about sailing is that the learning never stops. Even at home in familiar waters, we'd learn new things every year. Now that we're voyaging, the lessons are coming much faster. Posted on 14 Jan 2023
Our planetary system from a sailor's perspective
Event in Canada: Navagating with the stars This in-person presentation at the BCIT Planetarium is for everyone and anyone who has looked at stars and wondered how anyone could use their location to navigate with. Posted on 13 Jan 2023
Electrical Skills for Cruisers
Spend a day with electrical engineer, Bjarne Hansen Spend a day with electrical engineer, Bjarne Hansen, in an interactive session about all things boat electrical. Posted on 30 Dec 2022
Crewsaver 2021 Safetyline FOOTERGJW Direct 2024 DinghyMarine Products Direct 2023 - Calypso FOOTER