Please select your home edition
Edition
Selden 2020 - LEADERBOARD

More 'fairness' needed in conservation

by ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies 12 Jun 2021 05:58 UTC
Conservation practice and policy in low- and middle-income countries are often shaped by rich Western countries, which means they are underpinned by Western ideas about fairness © V Creative

New research shows what is often assumed to be 'fair' in conservation practice may not be considered so by the very people most affected by it—and a new approach is needed if protected areas are to be effective.

Lead author Dr Georgina Gurney, from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies based at James Cook University, said considering local stakeholder conceptions of fairness in conservation is critical.

"If conservation is perceived as unfair it can lead to conflict, undermining support and cooperation," Dr Gurney said.

She said it is not only an ethical matter but key to achieving good outcomes for people and the environment.

"But what is fairness? Very few studies have asked this question in the context of conservation, especially marine protected areas."

The researchers asked Indigenous communities in Fiji (who hold customary tenure rights to land and sea) about the fairness of five alternative approaches to distributing money paid by tourists to dive in a new co-managed marine protected area.

"Our study found local stakeholders considered the 'most fair' way to distribute money from the area was according to who held rights over the area," said co-author Dr Sangeeta Mangubhai, Director of the Wildlife Conservation Society Fiji Country Program.

"They thought the least fair way to distribute money was according to the costs incurred to fishers who were affected by the new rules prohibiting fishing."

The findings challenge common assumptions in much of the conservation literature and practice about what constitutes distributional fairness. These often focus on equality and forgone economic benefits of resource extraction, such as fishing.

"Our findings help clarify fairness in global environmental policies and agreements," Dr Mangubhai said. "Explicitly identifying what is considered fair by those most affected by conservation is important during both the planning and evaluation processes."

"This practice is especially important in low- and middle-income countries. Conservation practice and policy undertaken in these countries are often shaped by that developed in rich Western countries, which means they are underpinned by Western ideas about fairness."

"As the coverage of conservation areas is expected to grow to 30% of the world's surface by 2030, more attention should be given to what local stakeholders consider is fair with regards to related decision-making and the distribution of associated costs and benefits," Dr Gurney said.

"To help make sure existing and new protected areas work, we need to move beyond tacit assumptions about what constitutes fair management to explicit identification of local conceptions of fairness."

"Otherwise, we risk the chance of support for the protected area being eroded."

Paper

Gurney G, Mangubhai S, Fox M, Kiatkoski Kim M, Agrawal A. (2021). 'Equity in environmental governance: perceived fairness of distributional justice principles in marine co-management'. Environmental Science & Policy. DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2021.05.022

Related Articles

DNA reveals the past and future of coral reefs
New DNA techniques are being used to understand how coral reacted to the end of the last ice age New DNA techniques are being used to understand how coral reacted to the end of the last ice age in order to better predict how they will cope with current changes to the climate. Posted on 22 Oct 2022
The double burden of climate change
A new study on the effects of climate change in five tropical countries A new study on the effects of climate change in five tropical countries has found fisheries are in more trouble than agriculture, and poor people are in the most danger. Posted on 9 Jul 2022
Fade to grey
Fish communities become duller as coral reefs die James Cook University researchers have found brightly coloured fish are becoming increasingly rare as coral declines, with the phenomenon likely to get worse in the future. Posted on 26 Mar 2022
Concerns as development threatens reefs
A stark warning about the impacts of urban growth on the world's coral reefs A new study has delivered a stark warning about the impacts of urban growth on the world's coral reefs. Posted on 10 Mar 2022
New data shows coral everywhere face catastrophe
The refuges will provide almost no escape Alarming new research shows global warming of 1.5 degreesC relative to pre-industrial levels will be catastrophic for almost all coral reefs - including those once thought of as refuges. Posted on 4 Feb 2022
Coral identity crisis
A new way to distinguish and identify coral species Researchers have found a new way to distinguish and identify coral species—providing crucial information to help manage coral reefs in a warming world. Posted on 30 Nov 2021
Corals roll with the punches
Corals may be able to cope with climate change in the coming decades A new study suggests corals may be able to cope with climate change in the coming decades better than previously thought- but will still struggle with ever-faster rates of climate change. Posted on 8 Sep 2021
Measuring conservation in a way that counts
The term 'save' in conservation needs to be better defined A new study raises questions on whether current conservation science and policy for protected areas could be saving more biodiversity—with political and economic expediency often having taken precedence in the past. Posted on 30 Jul 2021
Time running out to save coral reefs
A window of opportunity to save the world's coral reefs - but time is running out New research on the growth rates of coral reefs shows there is still a window of opportunity to save the world's coral reefs - but time is running out. Posted on 13 May 2021
Half a trillion corals
World-first coral count prompts rethink of extinction risks For the first time, scientists have assessed how many corals there are in the Pacific Ocean—and evaluated their risk of extinction. Posted on 3 Mar 2021
Marine Products Direct 2023 - Calypso FOOTER2024 fill-in (bottom)J Composites J/99